Translate

Search This Blog

2018/03/17

Sea Kale Germination Experiment - Part 4 (Final Update)

We started an experiment about Sea Kale germination. We wanted to see if it made any difference if we soaked the seeds or if the pericarp (the outer layer) of the seed was removed or cracked. 
We put 2 seeds in each pot, and used 5 pots for each category. 

  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Removed - Floated 
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Removed - Sank
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Cracked
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Intact (all floated)
  • Not Soaked, Pericarp Removed
  • Not Soaked, Pericarp Cracked
  • Not Soaked, Pericarp Intact


We observed the pots checking for germination daily from Jan 26th through to March 16th.
It has been almost a month since our last seedling emerged (on Feb 22nd) and therefore, we are wrapping up this experiment. 




Sea Kale Experiment Results
Category
Container
Date 1st Sprout Emerged
Date 2nd Sprout Emerged
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Removed, Floated
1
Jan 29 - Seedling was not Sea Kale
-
2
-
-
3
Feb 1
-
4
Jan 28
Jan 29
5
Jan 31
Feb 6
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Removed, Sank
1
-
-
2
Feb 1
-
3
Feb 2
-
4
Feb 1
Feb 4
5
Feb 2
-
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Cracked
1
-
-
2
-
-
3
-
-
4
Feb 9
-
5
Feb 3*
-
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Intact
1
-
-
2
Feb 17
-
3
-
-
4
Feb 9
-
5
Feb 5
-
Not Soaked, Pericarp Removed
1
-
-
2
Feb 8
Feb 9
3
Feb 3
-
4
Feb 3
Feb 22
5
Feb 5
-
Not Soaked, Pericarp Cracked
1
-
-
2
-
-
3
Feb 4*
-
4
Feb 1
Feb 4
5
Feb 1
Feb 6
Not Soaked, Pericarp Intact
1
-
-
2
Feb 17
-
3
-
-
4
-
-
5
-
-


? - Not 100% sure it is a Sea Kale Seedling. Will know for certain when the true leaves emerge.
* The Seedling has emerged, but the pericarp is still over the cotyledons.




Summary of Results:
Category
Germination Rate
Average Number of Days for Germination
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Removed, Floated
5/10
50%
(7+3+4+5+12) ÷ 5
6.2 
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Removed, Sank
5/10
50%
(7+8+7+10+8) ÷ 5
8 
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Cracked
2/10
20%
(15+9) ÷ 2
12 
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Intact
3/10
20%
(23+15+11) ÷ 3
16 
Not Soaked, Pericarp Removed
6/10
60%
 (14+15+9+9+28+11) ÷ 6

14.3 
Not Soaked, Pericarp Cracked
5/10
50%
 (10+7+10+7+12) ÷ 5
9.2
Not Soaked, Pericarp Intact
1/10
10%
(23) ÷ 1

23




General Observations:

When comparing the soaked seeds to the ones which were not soaked. The ones which were not soaked overnight had better germination rates when the pericarp was removed or cracked.

The rates of germination for the pericarp being removed whether they floated or sank when soaked overnight was 50%. For those that were not soaked, the germination rate was 60%, However, due to the small sample size this might not be that much of a difference. 

With the pericarp cracked, the germination rate was lower when it was soaked overnight, 20% compared to the ones which were not soaked at 50%



When the pericarp was left intact, the soaked ones had a higher germination rate of 30% compared to 10% when not soaked. 




Conclusion:
It seems as though the best results for germination is when the pericarp is cracked or removed without soaking overnight.


If you are not going to remove the pericarp, soak the seeds before planting. 

__________________



This is a picture of the Sea Kale seedling which emerged with the pericarp cracked but the pericarp remained over the cotyledons.


We had a slight problem with dampening off for some of the seedlings, (in hindsight we probably should have sterilized our potting mix). We also lost a couple of seedlings when we transplanted them to larger pots. The rest are doing well but a bit leggy.


Here are a couple of pictures our other Sea Kale seedlings.




2018/02/05

Sea Kale Germination Experiment - Part 3

We are 11 days into our experiment and lots of Sea Kale seedlings have emerged!
More than we expected. :-)

The ones that we don't plant in our garden, we will be offering to friends, and to the City of Toronto Museums which have gardens.

Here are some pictures of the seedlings.





Here are the raw results of our Germination Experiment so far:

Sea Kale Experiment Results
Category
Container
Date 1st Sprout Emerged
Date 2nd Sprout Emerged
Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Removed, Floated
1
Jan 29? 

2


3
Feb 1

4
Jan 28?
Jan 29
5
Jan 31

Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Removed, Sank
1


2
Feb 1

3
Feb 2

4
Feb 1
Feb 4
5
Feb 2

Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Cracked
1


2


3


4


5
Feb 3*

Soaked Overnight, Pericarp Intact
1


2


3


4


5
Feb 5

Not Soaked, Pericarp Removed
1


2


3
Feb 3

4
Feb 3

5
Feb 5

Not Soaked, Pericarp Cracked
1


2


3
Feb 4*

4
Feb 1
Feb 4
5
Feb 1?

Not Soaked, Pericarp Intact
1


2


3


4


5



? - Not 100% sure it is a Sea Kale Seedling. Will know for certain when the true leaves emerge.
* The Seedling has emerged, but the pericarp is still over the cotyledons.


The two seedlings in the front of this picture emerged with the pericarp still covering the cotyledons. We won't be 'helping' them off. Hopefully they will come off on their own.

More pictures.


2018/01/29

Sea Kale Germination Experiment - Part 2

It has been 4 days since we sowed the seeds and we have some preliminary results.
3 seedlings have emerged!

All of them were from the set that were Soaked overnight, Pericarp removed and floated.
2 were in the same pot.


These 2 pots have been moved so they can be under grow lights now.
We will still keep checking on them to see if the 4th seed germinates.
(There are 2 seeds in each pot.)

All of the other pots are still being observed as well.

2018/01/25

Sea Kale Germination Experiment - Part 1

Today we started a little experiment with some Sea Kale seeds (Crambe Maritima)

We (Mom & I) got our seeds from FedCo Seeds.

Our Sample Size for this experiment is 70 Seeds.

We put 2 seeds in each pot and clearly labelled the outside of the pots.
We have 5 pots with seeds from each category below:
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Removed - Floated 
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Removed - Sank
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Cracked
  • Soaked overnight, Pericarp Intact (all floated)
  • Not Soaked, Pericarp Removed 
  • Not Soaked, Pericarp Cracked
  • Not Soaked, Pericarp Intact

All of the seeds were sown in soil from the same bag of potting soil that was warmed to room temperature over the course of a few days.


All of the seeds were placed about a 1/4 inch deep.
All of the containers in this experiment are 4 inch plastic pots.

They are all in the same room with the same environmental conditions where other plants are thriving. 



Predictions: 
 We expect that the seeds with the pericarp removed will be more likely to successfully sprout. However, we do not know if the pericarp will help or hinder germination - which is why we cracked some of them (for scarification) and left some intact.



We noticed that some of the seeds with the pericarp removed floated and some sank. We chose to separate these to find out if this is an indicator of viable seeds. 


Limitations:
We have never successfully germinated Sea Kale seeds before.
We are not looking at how light affects germination as all of the seeds were initially put under about a 1/4 inch of dirt. Watering may change the depth of the seeds, either exposing them, or covering them up more.
We did not look at how sowing the seeds directly outside would affect germination.
Also, I am totally inexperienced with designing Science experiments.




2018/01/15

Around Winchester

Dad and I wandered around Winchester on the last full day of our trip to England.
Here are some pictures: